
During fieldwork with Nayaka people in southern India, anthropologist Nurit Bird-David was shown two stones on a small platform among the houses. People told her how each stone had come to someone’s attention during an encounter in the forest. They treated those two stones as devaru, a local term Bird-David examines through stories, encounters and performances. The people who described them distinguished them from the many other stones nearby. That detail helps explain why “everything has a soul” is a poor summary of what scholars call animism. Read Bird-David’s field account.
How animism became a term in the study of religion
In Primitive Culture (1871), the British anthropologist Edward Burnett Tylor proposed “belief in Spiritual Beings” as a minimum definition of religion. He used animism for the doctrine of souls and other spiritual beings, including deities and lesser spirits. His argument gave readers a way to compare beliefs about dreams, death, ritual and worship across societies. It also organized societies into a Victorian hierarchy and treated some living communities as evidence for earlier stages of human culture. That hierarchy was part of Tylor’s explanation. The existence of similar practices in different places cannot, on its own, establish a common origin or a universal sequence. Read Chapter XI of Tylor’s Primitive Culture.
Anthropologists who revisited the term asked a different question. They examined how people learn to recognize someone they can address, respond to or have obligations toward. In that sense, personhood concerns participation in social relationships. “Person” here can have a wider meaning than “human being.” The range of beings involved and the conditions under which people relate to them vary from one community and encounter to another.
What the Nayaka examples show
Bird-David’s 1999 article draws on fieldwork from 1978–79 and a return visit in 1989. One woman told her that a particular stone had come toward her while she was digging for roots. A second account described a stone suddenly reaching a woman’s lap while she rested under a tree. The women brought the stones back to where they lived. In Bird-David’s analysis, the encounter was part of what made each stone recognizable as devaru. It mattered that people experienced the stone as doing something in relation to them.
Bird-David also describes communal performances in which participants spoke with, joked with and asked for help from devaru brought into the gathering by performers in trance. For her, these occasions helped people learn how to recognize and engage with devaru in other situations. She called this a relational epistemology, meaning a way of knowing that develops through participation and attention to how others respond. Her account concerns the people and practices she studied. Keeping the word devaru in the explanation preserves distinctions that a broad English word such as “spirit” can obscure. Read Bird-David’s study of encounters and performances.
Te Urewera in Tūhoe accounts of land and responsibility
A distinct example comes from Aotearoa New Zealand. Tūhoe describe Te Urewera as their ewe whenua, their place of origin and return. In the iwi’s account, Te Urewera sustains people with food, medicine and shelter and gives meaning to Tūhoe language, customs and identity. In a 2017 public lecture, Tāmati Kruger described being tangata whenua in terms of living with and caring for the land, including changing human behavior for its well-being. These are explanations in Tūhoe terms, grounded in a particular homeland and history. Read the Tūhoe account of their homeland. Read Kruger’s lecture.
The 2014 recognition of Te Urewera as a legal entity gave that relationship a place in public governance. At a 2017 discussion of Te Kawa o Te Urewera, the guiding document for the area, Kruger asked what people themselves needed to do differently when visiting or using the land. The legal entity, the responsibilities expressed in Tūhoe language and the encounters recorded among the Nayaka each belong to a different setting. Comparing them can help readers recognize how relationships shape behavior while keeping their different histories and meanings in view. Read the Tūhoe account of the 2017 discussion.
Conclusion
Animism has meant different things in the history of anthropology. Tylor used it to classify beliefs about spiritual beings. Bird-David used it to ask how a particular community comes to know beings through relationships. The Tūhoe account of Te Urewera adds a question about responsibility in a particular place. To understand any of these examples, start with the people’s own terms, the encounter or practice they describe, and what they say follows from it.
Published by Ralf. About our editorial process.




