Why Some Christian Churches Have Statues and Others Do Not

A close-up image of a beautifully carved statue of a saint or religious figure, set against the backdrop of a Gothic cathedral. - Christian churches, statues, religious art

Why Christian churches differ over statues and sacred images

Some churches place statues of Jesus, Mary, or saints near their altars; others give greater prominence to painted icons or leave the worship space comparatively plain. These differences reflect competing interpretations of the Bible, beliefs about how images function in worship, and particular artistic traditions. They cannot be explained by a simple division between Christians who value religious art and Christians who reject it.

A statue, an icon, and a crucifix are different categories

A statue is a three-dimensional sculptural form. An icon is a sacred image, a category that concerns its religious identity and use rather than just its material. A crucifix depicts Christ on the cross, whereas a plain cross has no figure of Christ. Consequently, asking whether a church has statues does not answer every question about its images.

As the Metropolitan Museum of Art explains, Byzantine icons appeared in many media, including panel painting, ivory, metal, fresco, and mosaic. It would therefore be misleading to define every icon as a flat wooden painting, or to treat every richly decorated church as a church full of freestanding statues.

The biblical disagreement concerns interpretation

Exodus 20:4–5 prohibits making images and bowing down to or serving them. Christians who oppose devotional images regard this prohibition as a powerful reason to exclude representations of God from worship. Their concern can extend beyond worshipping a statue as a separate deity to approaching God through an image at all.

Christians who permit images also read that passage, but interpret it alongside texts such as Exodus 25:18–22, where God commands the making of cherubim for the ark. For them, the presence of a crafted religious figure is not automatically idolatry. They distinguish a permitted image from the worship of a created object. The disagreement concerns what the commandment prohibits and how biblical examples apply to Christian worship.

Catholic teaching distinguishes veneration from adoration

The Catechism of the Catholic Church, paragraphs 2130–2132, connects sacred images with the Incarnation: the Christian belief that the Son of God became human. It also distinguishes the honor given to an image from the adoration due to God alone. In this account, honor is directed toward the person represented rather than toward wood, plaster, or stone as a divine substance.

A statue of a saint therefore does not officially identify that saint as another god. Catholic teaching provides a theological explanation for devotional images; it does not establish what every individual visitor understands or does. Someone who sees a person praying near a statue needs that distinction to understand Catholic practice, while recognizing that other Christian traditions dispute the practice itself.

Orthodox churches demonstrate why images do not mean statues

The Orthodox Church in America describes icons as witnesses to the presence of God’s kingdom and relates their use to Christ becoming human. Its explanation of icons and the iconostasis describes an ordered arrangement of Christ, Mary, angels, saints, and biblical scenes. These are theological claims about the place of images in Orthodox worship.

A Greek Orthodox guide to church decoration likewise discusses painted compositions and mosaics in particular parts of the building. A church can thus be rich in sacred figures without relying on freestanding statues. Neither the absence of such statues nor a preference for another medium establishes that a congregation rejects religious images.

Lutheran and Reformed positions are not interchangeable

Calling all Protestant churches “image-free” obscures significant differences. In a Lutheran explanation of crosses and crucifixes, artist Edward Riojas discusses the Christus Rex, a depiction of Christ as priest and king, and its use in Lutheran sanctuaries. This is a concrete example of a Protestant setting in which a representation of Christ can belong in the worship space. It contradicts the assumption that Protestant identity requires an empty cross or excludes every sculpted figure.

A stricter position appears in the Reformed Westminster Confession of Faith, chapter 21.1, which says that acceptable worship is limited by God’s revealed will and rejects worship through visible representations. The Westminster Larger Catechism, question 109, expressly rejects representations of God or any person of the Trinity. This identifies a particular confessional objection, rather than proving that every Protestant community forbids every kind of art. A landscape and a devotional representation of Christ do not raise identical questions under that teaching.

History includes conflicts within image-using traditions

The dispute is older than the Protestant Reformation. The Met’s account of Byzantine iconoclasm describes periods of opposition to religious figures in 726–787 and 815–843, involving church and imperial authority. These were distinct phases, rather than one uninterrupted policy lasting from 726 to 843. The cross remained an acceptable decorative form even when figural images were prohibited.

The Catholic Catechism identifies the Second Council of Nicaea in 787 with the defense of image veneration. The later return of Byzantine images in 843 also shaped subsequent church decoration. These controversies concerned the relationship between a sacred person and an image, as well as the proper direction of devotion. They cannot be reduced to a modern preference for elaborate or minimalist interiors.

A concrete example: a crucifix that emphasizes victory

Images within the same broad tradition can emphasize different aspects of Christian belief. The Met’s catalogue describes an Austrian crucifix dated about 1125–1150 in which Christ’s open eyes present him as alive, expressing the belief that he conquered death. The catalogue suggests that it may have stood on a beam or screen in a small church; that placement is a possibility, not a documented certainty.

This example shows why a crucifix should not automatically be interpreted as an exclusive emphasis on suffering. Its treatment of Christ’s body, clothing, and expression can contribute to a more particular theological message. Understanding the individual object matters alongside identifying the denomination of the building that contains it.

Fewer statues can also reflect restraint within a tradition

Even official approval of images does not call for unlimited decoration. The Catholic General Instruction of the Roman Missal calls for noble simplicity in church furnishings in paragraph 292. Paragraph 318 permits images of Christ, Mary, and the saints, while warning against indiscriminately increasing their number or arranging them so that they distract from the liturgical celebration.

A relatively restrained interior is therefore compatible with Catholic permission to use sacred images. Conversely, an Orthodox interior dominated by mosaics is not evidence of indifference to visual devotion. A particular church’s appearance needs to be understood through its own teaching, objects, and history; its continent alone does not supply a reliable explanation.

Conclusion

Christian churches, statues, religious art in ChristianityChristian churches differ over statues because they disagree about the permitted relationship between images and worship, and because they express their faith through different artistic forms. To understand a particular church, ask what is depicted, how the image is used, and which teaching explains its place. A statue, a painted icon, and a plain cross can each express a deliberate religious choice. Counting sculptures alone misses both the theological disagreements and the variety within Christian traditions.

Published by Ralf. About our editorial process.

Leave a Comment