Why People Join Groups Called Cults: Belonging, Commitment and Control

A captivating image depicting a group of people gathered around a charismatic leader in a dimly lit room, with an ominous yet intriguing atmosphere. - religious cults, psychology, motivation

People may join a religious group because its teachings seem convincing, its members become trusted friends, or it offers community and a way to change their lives. Those motives can coexist. Understanding them requires more than assuming that everyone who enters an unfamiliar movement is gullible or has lost the ability to choose.

A second question is what happens after someone becomes involved. A group can offer meaningful relationships while also placing harmful pressure on members. The reasons for joining, the reasons for staying and the obstacles to leaving need to be examined separately.

What does the word “cult” tell us?

In everyday speech, “cult” often expresses disapproval without specifying the conduct at issue. The religious-information charity Inform explains that the term has different uses and prefers to begin with a description of a movement’s beliefs and practices.

This approach does not deny that religious groups can harm people. It asks for a more precise account: what happened, who experienced it, and what evidence supports the claim? Calling a group unfamiliar, small or unconventional does not answer those questions.

“New religious movement” is also not a synonym for “abusive group.” It describes a field of religious activity, rather than certifying either safety or danger. Harmful conduct can occur in established institutions as well as in newer movements.

The concern in this article is how people become involved in groups and how commitment can develop into constrained choice. It does not assign every minority religion the same psychological profile.

Social relationships can open the door

In “Networks of Faith,” published in 1980, Rodney Stark and William Sims Bainbridge examined recruitment to three different religious groups. Their abstract reports strong support for the role of interpersonal networks and argues that relationships and the fit between a group’s message and a person’s circumstances are complementary explanations.

The implication is not that ideas never matter. A person can first encounter a teaching through someone they trust, then find the teaching persuasive. Friendship can create the opportunity to listen, while belief gives participation meaning.

The authors also note that social networks support commitment to conventional religions. Meeting a group through friends is therefore not, by itself, evidence of manipulation. The important further questions concern honesty, freedom and the conduct of those relationships.

Belonging and self-change are real attractions

Dominiek D. Coates’s study published in the Journal of Religion and Health in 2014 analysed life-history interviews with 23 former members of 11 Australian groups. The abstract describes a desire for stronger social connections, with different participants seeking guidance, direction or opportunities for self-change.

This evidence challenges a single story in which every participant is recruited through an irresistible technique. People described their involvement in relation to their lives and aspirations. The appeal of belonging should be taken seriously, even when later experiences were harmful.

The study is qualitative and based on former members’ accounts. It can illuminate experiences and possible pathways, but it cannot establish how common each motive is among everyone who has joined a religious movement.

Joining and staying are different decisions

A person may initially value a group for reasons that do not fully explain their later commitment. To explore this distinction, Coates’s 2012 study of “cult commitment” interviewed seven former members from four groups.

Its abstract reports that remaining involved was influenced both by the direct rewards of membership and by control exercised by leaders and the group. This matters because benefits and pressure need not be mutually exclusive. Someone can value friendships or a sense of purpose while also experiencing restrictions.

The small sample cannot describe every movement. Its contribution is a more useful question than “Why did they not simply leave?”: what was the person receiving from membership, and what limited their alternatives?

Consider a hypothetical participant who first attends a discussion because a friend invites them. Later, their closest relationships and everyday activities become concentrated within the group. Even if their beliefs remain sincere, deciding to leave now involves a different social situation from deciding whether to attend the first meeting.

Influence is not the same as unlimited control

The language of “brainwashing” can imply that a leader possesses a technique capable of erasing independent thought. It can also be used more loosely to describe intense social pressure. These meanings should not be treated as interchangeable.

In a 2016 article on conformity and commitment, Coates analysed accounts from 23 former members of 11 groups and proposed understanding the disputed concept along a continuum of social influence. The abstract acknowledges debate about how to distinguish ordinary socialization from harmful practices.

This does not mean that coercion is merely imaginary. It means that an explanation should identify the actual pressures and restrictions involved. Shared routines, admiration for a teacher and strong beliefs do not all carry the same implications as intimidation or the systematic removal of alternatives.

These papers should also not be treated as a series of independent population surveys. Related qualitative work can offer different analyses of participants’ experiences without establishing a universal recruitment formula.

What research on coercive control adds

Sarah E. Feliciano’s 2023 master’s thesis at CUNY applied a coercive-control framework to interviews with 52 former members of various groups, including psychological and self-help groups. Its abstract identifies manipulation, intimidation and close regulation of daily behaviour as frequently reported tactics.

The framework directs attention to patterns of power, rather than only to a leader’s personality. Questions about what a person can refuse, what happens when they disagree and how everyday choices are restricted become central.

The thesis is an exploratory study of former members, not a representative estimate of all religious groups. Its findings do not establish that every charismatic teacher is abusive or that every close-knit community uses coercion. Nor does an outsider’s impression justify diagnosing a leader with a personality disorder.

Cognitive dissonance: a possible process, not a complete explanation

Cognitive dissonance concerns inconsistency between psychologically important beliefs or actions. In their 1959 experiment on forced compliance, Leon Festinger and James Carlsmith studied participants who completed boring tasks and were then paid to describe them positively to someone else.

The study reported more positive subsequent evaluations in the one-dollar condition than in the twenty-dollar condition. The authors interpreted the difference in relation to the justification available for making a statement contrary to a private opinion.

This was a laboratory experiment, not a study of religious recruitment. It illustrates one proposed mechanism of attitude change; it does not establish why a particular person joined or stayed in a group. Applying the concept requires evidence about the relevant beliefs, actions and circumstances.

For example, someone might reinterpret a disappointing experience to preserve an important commitment. They might also revise the commitment or leave. Dissonance theory should not become a circular claim that either response proves the group has controlled their mind.

Assess conduct rather than stereotypes

Inform’s discussion of harmful groups emphasizes individual cases and notes that practices can differ between local centres or change over time. A description from one period or location should not automatically be treated as a complete account of every member’s experience.

Specific questions are more useful than an alarming label:

  • Are expectations about time, money and personal commitments explained before someone agrees?
  • Can members question leaders and obtain information from outside the group?
  • What happens when someone declines a request or decides to leave?
  • Are allegations supported by identifiable evidence, and how does the organization respond?

These questions concern accountability and choice. An unusual doctrine alone does not answer them, and a familiar institutional name does not remove the need to ask them.

Understanding a person without blaming them

Someone who has belonged to a harmful group may still value parts of the experience or care about people who remain. A simple demand to describe the entire experience as either good or bad can miss the mixture of relationships, hopes and pressures documented in research.

For people exploring a movement, Inform’s seeker guidelines recommend learning from several sources, examining concerns, maintaining outside relationships and allowing time before major commitments. These are practical ways to gather information; they are not a test that can certify a group as safe.

Understanding how involvement developed is also different from assigning responsibility for abuse. Finding a teaching attractive, trusting a friend or wanting community does not make someone responsible for another person’s harmful conduct.

Conclusion

There is no single explanation for why people join groups called cults. Research points to social relationships, the appeal of belonging and self-change, and combinations of meaningful benefits with restrictive practices. The balance differs between people and groups.

A careful account separates initial attraction from continued commitment and obstacles to leaving. It takes reports of harm seriously while examining evidence and avoiding stereotypes about minority religions or their members. The most useful focus is the person’s actual circumstances and the group’s conduct, rather than a claim that one label explains everything.

Published by Ralf. About our editorial process.

Leave a Comment