
Pastafarianism began as a satirical argument about science education and developed into a name people used for a community, the Church of the Flying Spaghetti Monster. In April 2016, two members married in a pirate-themed ceremony in Akaroa, New Zealand. A television report on the wedding prompted a complaint from the celebrant. The public record of that complaint shows how a joke about pirates became part of a dispute about how to describe a community. Henderson’s account of the Akaroa wedding Broadcasting Standards Authority decision 2016-042
How pirates entered the story
In 2005, Bobby Henderson addressed an open letter to the Kansas State Board of Education during a debate over intelligent design. He proposed that schools give classroom time to a creation story featuring a Flying Spaghetti Monster. The letter insisted on pirate clothing for teachers and displayed a chart linking the decline in pirate numbers to rising temperatures. The absurd correlation was part of the argument. Putting two trends on the same chart is easy. Demonstrating that one caused the other requires evidence. A reply published in June 2005 documents the letter’s circulation that year. The heading on the current reprint gives 2006, so the dated reply helps establish the earlier chronology. Bobby Henderson’s open letter June 2005 reply published on Henderson’s site The Flying Spaghetti Monster and science education
The pirate costume gives the letter a visual joke that people can reuse. In the original setting, it was part of a deliberately extravagant demand about how schools would have to teach the invented account. At the Akaroa wedding, people used pirate clothing as part of the ceremony. The same visual device could serve a different purpose in each setting. It could make a political point in a letter and help give a celebration its shared form. Bobby Henderson’s open letter Henderson’s account of the Akaroa wedding
What the New Zealand notice approved
In December 2015, the New Zealand Registrar-General published a notice approving the Church of the Flying Spaghetti Monster for the purposes of the Marriage Act 1955. The official list of celebrants explains that authority to solemnise marriages belongs to people appointed by the Registrar-General and listed as celebrants. The notice concerns the organisation’s role in that system. A description of what a group believes answers a separate question from whether a particular celebrant can perform a marriage. December 2015 New Zealand Gazette, notice 2015-go7246 New Zealand’s official list of celebrants
Karen Martyn was the celebrant at the Akaroa wedding. Henderson’s account records the use of a docked ship, pirate dress and colanders. He described the wedding as a celebration for the couple. Those details show how symbols associated with the Flying Spaghetti Monster had a use beyond the original controversy in Kansas. They were part of a wedding that the participants could take seriously while enjoying the costume and wordplay. Henderson’s account of the Akaroa wedding Broadcasting Standards Authority decision 2016-042
Why the broadcast drew a complaint
Newshub’s report described the church as a spoof religion and said that Pastafarians believed pirates were supreme beings from whom humans evolved. Martyn objected to both points. She said the description of the church was denigrating and asked why a reporter would use that label without the group describing itself that way. On the second point, she said that pirates were described as the first sentient beings created by the Flying Spaghetti Monster. Her complaint raised questions about how a news item distinguishes a reporter’s description from a group’s own account. Broadcasting Standards Authority decision 2016-042
MediaWorks said it regretted the hurt the report caused and argued that the wording fell short of the threshold for denigration. It also argued that the claim about pirates did not affect the audience’s understanding of the wedding. These were separate defences. The first concerned the tone of the label and its effect on a community. The second concerned the importance of a detail to the factual story. Broadcasting Standards Authority decision 2016-042
The Broadcasting Standards Authority decided the complaint in August 2016. It treated spoof religion as an opinion that the broadcaster could express in the context of the item. It found the language did not reach the threshold for discrimination or denigration in the code it was applying. On accuracy, the authority found that the pirate statement was incidental to the main news, which was the wedding and the organisation’s approval to conduct such ceremonies. It declined to uphold either part of the complaint. Broadcasting Standards Authority decision 2016-042
That reasoning separates two judgments an editor might otherwise conflate. A regulator can find that an imprecise phrase was immaterial to the story under a particular broadcasting standard. A reader seeking to understand the movement still needs to know who used the phrase and how a participant responded to it. The complaint and the ruling preserve both positions and identify the question the authority had to answer. Broadcasting Standards Authority decision 2016-042
Conclusion
The Kansas letter used a fictional creator and pirate clothing to test a claim about what belonged in science class. In Akaroa, pirate clothing helped give a wedding its character, and the broadcast complaint asked how that community should be represented. The marriage notice, the account of the ceremony and the regulator’s decision each document a different part of the story. Together they show how Pastafarian satire acquired a public life beyond the school board debate. Pastafarianism and religious accommodation claims
Published by Ralf. About our editorial process.




