What Is Religion? Belief, Practice and Belonging

Image of a beautifully adorned temple or mosque with people from diverse backgrounds gathered together in harmony. - Religion Guide

religion in Foundations of religionReligion is a broad term for ways people understand and respond to what they regard as sacred or spiritually significant. A religion can give shape to a person’s private life, organize a community around shared practices or do both. What the term includes depends partly on the question being asked. The experience of prayer, the rules of a shared ritual and the answer someone gives about their affiliation each tell us something different about religion. William James, Lecture II · Émile Durkheim, Book I, Chapter I · Pew Research Center, about the Religious Landscape Study

Personal experience and shared life

In The Varieties of Religious Experience, William James chose to study how individuals experience a relationship with what they consider divine. That choice made room for accounts of private devotion and changes in a person’s sense of purpose. James acknowledged that his lectures would give little attention to theology or religious institutions. He also understood the divine broadly enough to consider traditions with very different views of God. William James, Lecture II

Émile Durkheim asked how beliefs and rites around sacred things bind people into a moral community. For him, an object or practice becomes sacred through the way it is set apart and approached under special rules. He used the word church in the general sense of a community constituted by shared beliefs and rites. His definition draws attention to how groups teach people to treat certain times, places or actions differently from the rest of everyday life. Émile Durkheim, Book I, Chapter I

What a practice can tell us

Paul’s first letter to the Corinthians describes a gathering where Christians eat bread and drink from a cup in remembrance of Jesus. Paul also rebukes participants who eat their own food while others go hungry. His instruction to wait for one another shows how the meaning of the meal and the obligations people owe each other belong to the same discussion. A description of the ritual alone would miss the dispute over how the community should live it. 1 Corinthians 11:17–34

The Buddhist discourse on setting the wheel of Dhamma in motion describes suffering, its origin in craving, its cessation and a path to that cessation. The Eightfold Path includes speech and livelihood as well as mindfulness and concentration. The teaching therefore concerns how a person acts throughout the day, including how they speak and earn a living. These two texts give different accounts of what a religious practice is meant to accomplish. 1 Corinthians 11:17–34 · Discourse on Setting the Wheel of Dhamma in Motion

Belonging, believing and practicing

A survey needs questions that people can answer in a consistent way. The U.S. Religious Landscape Study asks separately about religious identity, beliefs and practices. For a count of affiliation, a person’s reported religious identity is the relevant answer. A question about worship attendance or about how spiritual someone feels measures another aspect of their life. Someone can report the same affiliation at two points in life while changing how they pray, what they believe or how often they join a gathering. Pew Research Center, about the Religious Landscape Study · Pew Research Center, “Religious Switching”

Conclusion

A definition of religion is most precise when it tells us what it is trying to explain. James brings personal experience into focus. Durkheim shows why shared rites and responsibilities matter. A survey can track identities by asking people how they describe themselves. When reading about a particular religion, it helps to ask what its members do, what those actions mean to them and how they understand belonging. The answers make the broad term concrete.

Published by Ralf. About our editorial process.

Leave a Comment