
In the 2023–24 U.S. Religious Landscape Study, 5% of adults described themselves as atheists. About 29% were classified as religiously unaffiliated, a larger group that included atheists, agnostics and people who selected “nothing in particular.” The gap matters because questions about belief in gods, religious identity and participation in a community measure different things. The distinction helps explain where atheism fits in the study of religion. See the Religious Landscape Study’s results on religious identity.
What someone means by atheism
The word atheism can describe the absence of belief in gods. In philosophy of religion it often refers to the more specific claim that there are no gods. Under the first usage, someone who has suspended judgment may count as an atheist because they lack the belief. Under the second, the same person would need to affirm that gods do not exist. Agnosticism often concerns uncertainty or what can be known. An individual can use both labels if they use one to describe belief and the other to describe knowledge. Read Paul Draper’s discussion of the terms.
The words people select on a survey are another matter. A respondent can pick the label that seems closest to their identity without adopting a philosopher’s exact definition. Survey analysts can then see how those labels relate to other answers, such as certainty about belief, affiliation with a congregation or how often someone participates in worship.
What changes when a survey asks about belief
Pew’s questionnaire asked about present religion and listed atheist, agnostic and “nothing in particular” among the responses. Elsewhere it asked, “Do you believe in God or a universal spirit?” It then asked people who answered yes or no how certain they were. The first question lets respondents name an identity. The second asks about belief using wording broad enough to cover more than a personal creator. The third records how confidently respondents hold their view. Read the survey questionnaire.
Among U.S. adults who described their religion as “nothing in particular,” 69% answered yes to the question about God or a universal spirit. So did 43% of self-described agnostics and 7% of self-described atheists. The combined wording means a yes does not distinguish belief in God from belief in a universal spirit. A separate question found that 24% of self-identified atheists described themselves as at least somewhat spiritual. That response measures how people use the word spiritual about themselves, leaving room for different understandings of it. Read Pew’s findings on belief. See the separate results on spiritual self-description.
Why “no religion” can give a different number
The 2021 census in England and Wales asked a voluntary question about religion and offered “No religion” as a response. The Office for National Statistics reports that 37.2% of usual residents chose it, with the percentage calculated across all usual residents, including people who skipped the question. The figure describes affiliation in that census. Someone can choose “No religion” and still hold beliefs about God or the afterlife. Others may identify with a religion through family or culture and attend services infrequently. See the census results and how the percentage was calculated.
Setting that 37.2% beside the U.S. figure of 5% for atheists would mix an affiliation category with a specific identity, as well as populations of different ages and questions asked in different years. To compare atheism across places, first check which meaning is being measured, which response options were offered and who was counted.
Can a religious community be non-theistic?
It can. The New York Society for Ethical Culture describes its practice as non-theistic and places ethical conduct at the center of its understanding of religion. It also says it has no theological test for participation. That combination illustrates how a community can define itself through shared responsibilities and collective life while leaving room for members to hold different beliefs about God. An individual’s atheism and a community’s decision to organize around non-theistic practices answer two different questions. Read the Society’s account of its practice.
Conclusion
Atheism answers a question about gods, while religious identity and participation tell us how people describe themselves and take part in a community. The U.S. survey makes these differences visible by asking separate questions. The England and Wales census shows what an affiliation figure alone can tell us. Read the question and its answer choices before using a statistic about religion to draw a conclusion about belief.
Published by Ralf. About our editorial process.




