Scottish Presbyterianism | How Elders and Assemblies Took Shape

A stained-glass window depicting a Presbyterian church with symbols representing key aspects of the faith. - Presbyterianism unique

Presbyterianism unique in Christianity

Presbyterian churches are governed through councils in which elders and ministers share responsibility. In Reformation Scotland that arrangement developed through proposals about who could serve, how long an elder should hold office, and which bodies could oversee congregations. Two Books of Discipline and a parliamentary act let readers follow those questions through several stages.

Why the First Book proposed elections every year

The First Book of Discipline of 1560 laid out proposals for reforming the Scottish kirk, or church. It called for the names of candidates for elder and deacon to be read before the congregation and allowed further names to be put forward. It proposed annual elections and allowed elders to be returned to office. The stated reason was to prevent people from using a long tenure to encroach on the church’s freedom. Elders were to assist the minister in public affairs and discipline, and the text also gave them a role in admonishing a minister whose conduct warranted it. This was a proposal about how to exercise oversight in both directions. First Book of Discipline, 1560

How the Second Book recast the office

The Second Book of Discipline of 1578 describes eldership as a continuing spiritual calling. Someone lawfully called to it was expected to remain an elder, though the text allowed groups of elders to take turns in active service. It distinguishes the work of elders from that of deacons, who collect and distribute church goods under the direction of the eldership. Elders assist the pastor, visit the sick and bring matters that cannot be resolved privately before an assembly. The book also describes assemblies for one or more congregations, a province, a whole nation, and potentially several nations. That wider structure matters when a matter exceeds the charge of one congregation. Second Book of Discipline, 1578

What Parliament recognized in 1592

An act of the Scottish Parliament in 1592 recognized local sessions, presbyteries, provincial assemblies and general assemblies. It also set terms for the crown’s involvement in arranging the next General Assembly when the king or his commissioner was present. The law therefore records both a set of church institutions and their relationship with political authority at that moment. A later settlement annulled intervening acts that had restored powers to bishops. The parliamentary record shows why the history has several dates, even though the role of elected elders provides a thread through it. Scottish Parliament’s act of 1592 · Later parliamentary settlement of church government

Conclusion

The First Book asked how a congregation could choose elders and hold them accountable. The Second Book treated eldership as a lasting office and explained how it belonged within a system of assemblies. The 1592 act recognized specific bodies through which the kirk governed. Reading the documents together makes it possible to trace the development of Presbyterian government and to distinguish its Scottish history from the particular rules used by Presbyterian denominations today. Presbyterian elders, councils and sacraments

Published by Ralf. About our editorial process.

Leave a Comment