Separation of Church and State | How Massachusetts Ended Religious Taxes

A stylized illustration of a balance scale with a church on one side and a government building on the other, symbolizing the delicate balance between religion and governance. - separation of church and state

separation of church and state in Places of Worship

Separation of church and state concerns what public authorities may do about religion and what religious bodies can decide for themselves. The principle becomes more concrete when public money is involved. Massachusetts once required communities to support public worship and Protestant religious teaching. That arrangement continued after ratification of the federal First Amendment and ended through a change to the state’s own constitution. The example shows why the level of government and the date both matter. Massachusetts General Court, state constitution · Massachusetts court opinion on the state’s history of religious assessments · U.S. National Archives, First Amendment

Massachusetts protected worship and financed it

The 1780 Massachusetts Declaration of Rights protected worship in accordance with conscience, subject to conditions concerning the peace and the worship of others. It also directed the state legislature to require towns, parishes and similar bodies to make provision for public worship and Protestant religious teachers when voluntary support was insufficient. A person could ask for payments to support a teacher from their own denomination if they attended that teacher’s instruction. Otherwise the money could go to the local parish or precinct. Freedom in the manner of worship and the obligation to support worship were separate questions under this arrangement. Massachusetts General Court, state constitution · Massachusetts court opinion on the state’s history of religious assessments

The First Amendment addressed a different government

The First Amendment, ratified in 1791, bars Congress from making laws respecting an establishment of religion or prohibiting its free exercise. The Bill of Rights originally restricted the federal government. The Massachusetts provision belonged to state law, so it remained in effect after 1791. In the twentieth century, the U.S. Supreme Court recognized the Free Exercise and Establishment Clauses as applying to state and local governments through the Fourteenth Amendment. That later development is part of the history of the clauses and explains why their modern reach differs from their original reach. U.S. National Archives, First Amendment · Constitution Annotated, incorporation table

What changed in 1833

Massachusetts replaced its original provision with Article XI of the amendments. The new text allowed religious societies to choose and support their own ministers, maintain places of worship and raise money for their work. It provided for people to leave a religious society by filing notice and promised equal legal protection for peaceful religious denominations. In its account of the change, the state’s highest court explains that the amendment ended religious assessments. The responsibility for supporting religious societies shifted to those societies and their members. Massachusetts General Court, state constitution · Massachusetts court opinion on the state’s history of religious assessments

Conclusion

Massachusetts shows that protection for worship, the use of tax revenue and the power to govern a religious body are distinct issues. In 1833 the state changed who could require and collect support for worship. The federal First Amendment had a different legal history. The comparative guide to secularism explores how other countries have framed related questions.

Published by Ralf. About our editorial process.

Leave a Comment