Rational Atheism and the Burden of Proof

A minimalist design featuring a brain, a question mark, and an 'X' symbol overlaid on top of each other. - rational atheism

rational atheism in Foundations of Religion“Rational atheism” can describe an approach to belief in gods that asks what reasons there are for accepting a claim and what weight those reasons carry. Two influential arguments about evidence come from Bertrand Russell and Antony Flew. Russell asks whether an assertion deserves belief merely because it is difficult to disprove. Flew asks where discussion should start. Both make it important to distinguish withholding belief from asserting that a god does not exist. Bertrand Russell, Is There a God? · Antony Flew, The Presumption of Atheism

What Russell’s teapot is meant to show

In an essay written in 1952, Russell imagined claiming that a small china teapot orbited the sun between Earth and Mars. He specified that it was too small to be seen even with the most powerful telescopes. A person making the claim could therefore challenge sceptics to disprove it. Russell’s point was that their inability to do so supplies no evidence for the teapot. He went on to imagine the claim being taught as a venerable tradition. Social acceptance might change how people treat a doubter while leaving the original question of evidence open. Bertrand Russell, Is There a God?

Why Flew called his starting point negative atheism

In 1972, Flew proposed beginning an argument about God with what he called negative atheism. In his usage, a negative atheist has yet to accept theism. A positive atheist makes the further claim that God does not exist. Flew acknowledged that his use of “atheism” as an umbrella for both was unusual. He proposed that the person arguing for God’s existence first explain the concept of God being used and then offer reasons to believe that anything answers to it. Antony Flew, The Presumption of Atheism · Atheism and agnosticism

This is a rule Flew proposed for conducting a discussion. Its application starts by asking what the assertion actually is. A claim about a deity who is expected to intervene in a specified way calls for a different investigation from a claim about an ultimate cause of the universe. A person who makes a positive assertion of nonexistence is also advancing a conclusion that calls for reasons. Antony Flew, The Presumption of Atheism · Arguments from suffering and divine hiddenness

When a missing observation counts against a claim

Philosopher Elliott Sober discusses an example from Arthur Eddington. A net catches only fish longer than ten inches. That result could look like evidence about every fish in the lake. Learning that the openings in the net are ten inches across changes what the catch tells us. The method is expected to miss the small fish even if they are present. The evidential question is what we should expect to find under the competing explanations and whether we were in a position to find it. Elliott Sober on absence of evidence

That distinction matters in arguments about religion. An argument from divine hiddenness, for example, needs to explain why a particular conception of God would lead us to expect a clearer relationship or awareness than some people experience. The absence matters to the degree that the expectation is justified. This is a separate argument from simply asking the person making an assertion to give reasons for it. Elliott Sober on absence of evidence · Arguments from suffering and divine hiddenness

Conclusion

Russell’s example explains why an assertion’s resistance to disproof gives little reason to accept it. Flew separates a provisional starting point from a positive claim about what exists. An argument based on missing evidence adds a further step. It has to show what evidence the claim leads us to expect and why its absence should change our judgment.

Published by Ralf. About our editorial process.

Leave a Comment