A fatwa is an opinion about a question of Islamic law, given by a qualified scholar or a body that performs that role. The person who gives such opinions is called a mufti. A fatwa might answer a question from one person or address an issue that concerns a wider community. The circumstances matter in both cases. A religious authority may need to know how a product is made, what food people normally eat or whether its answer will have a formal effect under local law. Egypt’s Dar al-Ifta, explanation of a fatwa · Islamic Religious Council of Singapore, example on cultivated meat
How a question becomes an opinion
Egypt’s Dar al-Ifta describes a process that starts with understanding the question and the circumstances in which it arose. A mufti considers who is asking, where the situation occurs and whether the question concerns an individual or a wider audience. The next task is to determine which area of jurisprudence applies. The institution’s account then describes reasoning from sources such as the Qur’an and the Sunna, scholarly consensus and analogy, before applying the resulting judgment to the case. The stages describe that institution’s approach and explain why a change in the facts can matter. Dar al-Ifta, elements and stages of issuing a fatwa
Dar al-Ifta also distinguishes this work from that of a qadi, or judge. A mufti explains how an Islamic legal rule applies to a question. A judge’s decision resolves a matter before a court and can have consequences for the parties to that case. The distinction concerns what the two authorities are doing with the rule. It leaves a further question about whether a particular jurisdiction gives formal effect to certain published fatwas. Dar al-Ifta, the roles of jurist, mufti and judge

Singapore’s example of cultivated meat
In February 2024 the Islamic Religious Council of Singapore reported that its Fatwa Committee had studied cultivated meat and consulted scientists and people in the industry. The committee considered the origin of the cells, the production process and the ingredients. Its guidance treated the meat as permissible to eat under conditions. These included obtaining the cells from an animal permissible to eat, using permissible ingredients in the product and ensuring that the result was clean and non-toxic. Islamic Religious Council of Singapore, February 2024 announcement
The conditions explain what the committee’s answer does. It identifies features that would matter in assessing a particular product. The council also distinguishes this guidance from certification of an individual food product and leaves consumption of certified products to the individual. The example shows how technical knowledge about a production process can inform a religious opinion about it. Islamic Religious Council of Singapore, guidance and certification
What publication in a government gazette can do
Malaysia’s Administration of Islamic Law (Federal Territories) Act 1993 gives a specific role to publication in the Federal Gazette. Section 34 describes publication as the step that gives the mufti’s statement formal status as a fatwa under the Act. It says a published fatwa binds Muslim residents of the Federal Territories as a religious duty, subject to the exception stated for personal observance, belief or opinion where Islamic law permits departure. It also directs courts in the territories to recognize the published fatwa as authoritative on the matters it addresses. Malaysia, Act 505, section 34, English text
A gazette notice published in December 2024 illustrates the process. It records consultation with the Islamic Legal Consultative Committee and sets the zakat fitrah rate for 2025 in Kuala Lumpur, Putrajaya and Labuan. The schedule bases its rates on the prices of particular kinds of rice. The date, the named territories and the reference to section 34 identify the reach of this particular ruling. Malaysia, Federal Government Gazette P.U. (B) 523, December 24, 2024
Conclusion
A fatwa connects a question about real circumstances with an interpretation of Islamic law. Singapore’s cultivated meat guidance shows why the facts behind a question matter. The Malaysian notice shows why the method of publication and the named jurisdiction can matter as well. The issuing authority, its reasons and the scope of the published answer tell readers how to understand what a particular fatwa does.
Published by Ralf. About our editorial process.




