Secularism | Teaching About Religion in French Schools

A minimalist illustration of a globe with overlays of interlocking gears symbolizing the complexities of secularism. - Secularism

Secularism in Modern Religion and Spirituality

A pupil looking at a Botticelli painting asks who the woman in it is. In a 2002 report to France’s education minister, Régis Debray used a question like this to make a point about teaching in a secular school. Identifying the Virgin Mary can be necessary to understand the artwork. A pupil’s own beliefs are a separate matter. France’s school charter and Debray’s report show how laïcité can shape the way a classroom approaches religion. Régis Debray, L’enseignement du fait religieux dans l’École laïque, 2002 · French Ministry of National Education, Charter for Laïcité in Schools

What the school charter asks of teachers

The French Ministry of National Education publishes the Charter for Laïcité in Schools. It connects the principle with freedom of conscience and with protecting pupils from pressure to adopt a conviction. Article 11 concerns staff and sets a duty of neutrality in the exercise of their functions. Article 12 concerns the scope of teaching. It says that a subject can be examined through scholarly and educational inquiry and that pupils’ convictions cannot be invoked to contest a teacher’s right to cover a topic in the curriculum. The two articles distinguish the teacher’s professional role from the material a class may study. French Ministry of National Education, Charter for Laïcité in Schools

What Debray proposed in 2002

Debray argued that knowledge of religious traditions can help pupils interpret works of art, literature and historical events. His report proposed developing the relevant material within existing school subjects and preparing teachers to handle it. An art teacher and a history teacher may ask different questions about the same religious object. The report puts the emphasis on the methods and preparation of those teachers. Régis Debray, L’enseignement du fait religieux dans l’École laïque, 2002

What a lesson on a painting might cover

Botticelli’s Madonna of the Magnificat at the Uffizi gives a concrete example. Mary sits with the child Jesus and writes in a book. The gallery identifies the words as the opening of the Magnificat, the song of praise attributed to Mary in Luke 1. A class might compare the written passage with the way Botticelli gives it visual form and ask what the choice to show Mary writing contributes to the image. The subject is religious, and the activity is an analysis of how a painting uses a text. Uffizi, Botticelli’s Madonna of the Magnificat · Luke 1:46–55, NRSVUE

Conclusion

In this French school context, laïcité concerns how the institution teaches and protects pupils’ freedom of conscience. Debray’s example shows why knowledge of religion can belong in that work. A class can learn to identify Mary, recognise the words in the painting and explain their significance. The learning can be assessed through what students understand about the artwork and its sources.

Published by Ralf. About our editorial process.

Leave a Comment