The Noble Eightfold Path brings together understanding, ethical conduct and training of the mind. In the early Buddhist discourse SN 45.8, its factors are right view, intention, speech, action, livelihood, effort, mindfulness and concentration. Two of these factors, right effort and right mindfulness, help explain how the path works. One concerns what to cultivate or abandon. The other includes recognising what is happening in the mind and how it comes about. SN 45.8, Analysis of the Path
The four tasks of right effort
SN 45.8 divides right effort into four tasks. The first two concern unskillful states. The practitioner works to prevent them from arising and to abandon those that have already arisen. The next two concern skillful states. The practitioner works to bring them into being and to sustain and develop those that are already present. The distinction turns on both the quality of a state and whether it has arisen. SN 45.8, Analysis of the Path
Ill will gives a concrete example. SN 46.51 says that dwelling on what provokes irritation can feed ill will. The discourse also describes ways of directing attention that deprive it of that support. Its translator gives goodwill and compassion as examples of the release of mind discussed there. Effort in this setting can involve changing what one keeps attending to. SN 46.51, Food
How mindfulness recognises a hindrance
The four foundations of mindfulness are contemplation of the body, feelings, mind and phenomena or mental qualities. They describe the scope of right mindfulness. In MN 10, the section on mental qualities asks a practitioner to recognise whether a hindrance such as ill will is present and to discern how it arises, how it is abandoned and what prevents it from returning. The same discourse treats mindfulness, investigation, energy, joy, tranquillity, concentration and equanimity as seven factors of awakening. Those seven describe qualities to develop and form a separate list from the eight path factors. SN 45.8, Analysis of the Path · MN 10, Discourse on the Foundations of Mindfulness
How effort and mindfulness support right speech
MN 117 connects right view, effort and mindfulness to right speech. Right view distinguishes speech that should be abandoned, such as lying, divisive talk or abuse, from speech consistent with the path. Effort is applied to leaving the first kind behind and adopting the second. Mindfulness helps the practitioner keep that task in view. MN 117, The Great Forty
For example, someone might notice ill will while preparing to send a reply. Recognising it and the conditions that sustain it is an example of the attention described in MN 10. They can then stop composing an insult and respond to the matter truthfully and without abuse. The exercise of right speech draws on mindfulness and effort in the same situation. This is one way the factors reinforce one another in practice. MN 10, Discourse on the Foundations of Mindfulness · MN 117, The Great Forty
Conclusion
Right effort asks which states need to be prevented, abandoned, developed or sustained. Right mindfulness helps the practitioner recognise those states and see the conditions that support them. MN 117 brings both into the practice of right speech. It shows how training the mind and changing conduct can happen together on the Eightfold Path.
Published by Ralf. About our editorial process.
