Mormon fundamentalism refers to movements that claim to preserve teachings and practices of early Mormonism that The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints later discontinued or interpreted differently. Plural marriage is especially important, but questions of priesthood authority, revelation and religious continuity are also central.
These movements are not one organization. The Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints, commonly called the FLDS, is one group within a wider landscape. Fundamentalist groups must also be distinguished from The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, which does not authorize plural marriage today.
The historical background: plural marriage and change
Plural marriage in this setting means a man having more than one wife. The Church’s historical essay on its ending describes nineteenth-century members who understood the practice as a divine commandment and the growing pressure of United States antipolygamy legislation.
In 1890, Church President Wilford Woodruff issued the Manifesto. The essay acknowledges that ending the practice was a process: some new marriages occurred after 1890, and existing plural families did not all immediately dissolve.
This history makes a simple before-and-after account inadequate. A public policy, the treatment of established families and the performance of new marriages were related but distinct issues.
The Church understands both the introduction and ending of plural marriage through revelation. Fundamentalists disputed the legitimacy or meaning of the change. The disagreement therefore involved how religious authority could direct change, not only whether people preferred a particular household arrangement.
What changed in 1904?
The McKay Library’s presentation of the 1904 statement identifies a further declaration by President Joseph F. Smith, often called the Second Manifesto.
It warned that those entering or solemnizing new plural marriages would face excommunication. The library also distinguishes the continuation of existing family arrangements from permission to establish new ones.
For understanding fundamentalism, the significance is the sharpening boundary between authorized Church practice and people determined to continue plural marriage. The historical development cannot be explained by pretending nothing changed after 1890 or that every consequence was settled on the day the first Manifesto appeared.
How fundamentalist movements developed
A historical chapter published by Cambridge University Press traces the movement from the 1890 Manifesto and describes adherents coalescing into formal organization in the late 1920s. Its account places the beginnings of later groups within disputes about preserving what believers understood as the true religion.
Earlier Mormon leaders, scriptures and practices provided the inherited material. The distinct fundamentalist movements emerged through later claims about which parts of that inheritance remained binding and who had authority to preserve them.
That distinction prevents an important confusion: nineteenth-century plural marriage and twentieth-century fundamentalist organizations are connected subjects, but they are not identical historical institutions.
Scripture, covenant and sealing authority
Doctrine and Covenants 132, recorded in 1843, provides an important scriptural setting for disputes about marriage. The section addresses covenant, marriage beyond death, sealing authority and plural marriage.
Sealing concerns a religious claim about relationships with enduring significance beyond mortal life. In the text, authority matters: a covenant is not made eternally effective simply because someone privately wishes it to be.
This helps explain why disputes over plural marriage become disputes over priesthood. If a religious ordinance requires authorized performance, people disagreeing with Church policy must also explain who can validly perform it.
The continued presence of a historical text in scripture does not by itself establish present authorization for every practice it discusses. The Church and fundamentalists reach different conclusions about authority and application.
More than one claim to continuity
In his 1998 study in Dialogue, historian D. Michael Quinn identifies three recurring features: belief that the Church has departed from its proper course, commitment to plural marriage as a religious principle, and acceptance of priesthood authority outside the Church’s authorization.
Quinn also distinguishes organized groups from independents. His study discusses the FLDS, the Apostolic United Brethren and other communities rather than presenting a single movement with one leader.
These distinctions matter for religious thought. Shared criticism of a Church policy does not settle succession, leadership or the boundaries of a new community. Different answers to those questions can produce further divisions.
Quinn’s research is a dated historical source. Its membership estimates and descriptions of leaders should not be treated as a current directory of these communities.
Short Creek: a specific historical event
The major Short Creek raid occurred in 1953. In testimony published for a 2008 U.S. Senate hearing, Arizona Attorney General Terry Goddard described the operation of July 26, 1953 and the removal of children into state custody.
The testimony also recalled public criticism of the intervention and the consequences of separating families. It is evidence of a specific event and a later official assessment, rather than a reason to describe every subsequent intervention as identical.
For religious history, such events help explain collective memories of pressure and mistrust. They also show why the experiences of children and families belong alongside the statements of leaders.
Women’s lives require evidence beyond doctrine
Statements about patriarchal authority do not, by themselves, tell us everything about women’s relationships or experiences. Janet Bennion Cannon’s 1990 exploratory study examined female networking in the fundamentalist community at Pinesdale, Montana.
The study’s abstract identifies both a strong patriarchal ideology and women’s groups. It investigates the conditions supporting those groups, including economic independence and family organization.
This illustrates what ethnographic research can add: attention to social relationships and the ways people act within a community’s structures. It does not establish that every woman in every fundamentalist group has the same choices or experiences.
A fuller account needs to distinguish what leaders prescribe, what members say they believe and what people experience in practice. Current members, former members and children should not be treated as interchangeable voices.
Documented crimes and the limits of generalization
Specific wrongdoing must be stated clearly. In its August 9, 2011 statement, the Texas Department of Public Safety reported Warren Jeffs’s convictions for aggravated sexual assault of a child and sexual assault of a child, with sentences of life imprisonment and twenty years.
Those are documented criminal convictions, not merely disagreement over a controversial theology. Religious claims do not transform abuse into a harmless difference of interpretation.
At the same time, a conviction establishes facts about the case and offender. It does not establish that every member of the FLDS, every independent fundamentalist or every Latter-day Saint committed the same acts.
Distinguishing institutions and religious claims
The Church’s statement clarifying polygamy explicitly rejects affiliation with polygamous groups. Its position needs to be distinguished from the fundamentalist claim to preserve an earlier religious inheritance.
Both statements can be described accurately: one concerns present institutional affiliation, the other a claim about religious continuity. Reporting a claim does not require accepting its divine authorization.
Conclusion
Mormon fundamentalism is best understood through plural marriage, disputes over continuing revelation and competing claims to priesthood authority. The Manifestos of 1890 and 1904, later organizational development and different group histories explain why it cannot be reduced to one unchanged branch founded by nineteenth-century leaders.
Understanding the movement also requires attention to lived experience and documented harm. Distinguishing institutions, theological claims, historical research and specific criminal findings provides a fuller account than either romanticizing preservation of tradition or treating every community and member as identical.
Published by Ralf. About our editorial process.




