
Agnosticism commonly describes a position of uncertainty about whether a god exists. For the Victorian biologist Thomas Henry Huxley, who introduced the label agnostic, it also meant a way of deciding when a claim was warranted. In 1889 he debated the theologian Henry Wace in print. Their exchange moved from the meaning of the word to a question about testimony. What grounds did readers have for accepting words and events reported in the Gospels? A story involving a herd of pigs made their different approaches visible. Thomas Henry Huxley’s “Agnosticism” Henry Wace’s reply in The Nineteenth Century Huxley’s “Agnosticism: A Rejoinder” Agnosticism, belief and knowledge
Huxley’s rule for making claims
Huxley recalled choosing the term when he found himself among members of the Metaphysical Society, where people with sharply different religious and philosophical convictions discussed their views. He coined a label that made room for someone who felt unable to assent to the systems on offer. In his 1889 essay, he explained agnosticism as a method. One should follow reason as far as it goes and withhold claims of certainty where the evidence falls short. That standard applied to what he could reasonably affirm about a specific proposition. Thomas Henry Huxley’s “Agnosticism”
There is a difference between saying that a question is still open and saying that no one could ever answer it. Huxley’s method allows judgments about the strength of particular grounds. A person can take one report seriously, find another poorly supported and leave a third question open. This helps explain why agnosticism in his essay produced different judgments about different claims, even though he applied the same principle to each. Thomas Henry Huxley’s “Agnosticism” Agnosticism, belief and knowledge
What Wace thought the debate was about
Wace answered in the March 1889 issue of The Nineteenth Century. He distinguished what a person could establish through observation and reason alone from the supernatural revelation on which he said Christianity rested. For him, the important question was whether there was good reason to trust that Jesus had given the teaching attributed to him. Wace drew attention to the Lord’s Prayer and the Sermon on the Mount as expressions of that teaching. His argument concerned the authority and character of the witness a Christian receives. Henry Wace’s reply in The Nineteenth Century Tufts Digital Library’s 1889 volume of the exchange
Huxley’s rejoinder pressed on an earlier link in that chain. Before deciding whether to trust a teacher’s words, a reader needs grounds for attributing those words to the teacher. Huxley asked what could be established from documents whose accounts sometimes differed. The disagreement therefore had two levels. One concerned whether revelation could ground belief. The other concerned what the surviving texts could establish about its transmission. Henry Wace’s reply in The Nineteenth Century Huxley’s “Agnosticism: A Rejoinder”
One story, several accounts
Mark 5 tells of Jesus meeting a man described as possessed. The spirits leave him and enter a herd of pigs, which rush into the water. Luke 8 also tells of one man. Matthew 8 tells of two. The place name varies across the accounts and their manuscripts. The New American Bible identifies the place in Mark and Luke with the Gerasenes and in Matthew with the Gadarenes, and its notes show that other readings exist. A reader can check those differences without first taking a position on the miracle. Mark 5:1–20 and textual notes Matthew 8:28–34 and textual notes Luke 8:26–39 and textual notes
Mark and Luke include the name Legion and describe the man asking to go with Jesus after the encounter. In both accounts Jesus sends him home. Matthew gives a shorter account and ends with the people of the town asking Jesus to leave. Those endings direct attention to different parts of the story. They are also one reason to read each passage in full before treating the three as interchangeable summaries. Mark 5:1–20 and textual notes Matthew 8:28–34 and textual notes Luke 8:26–39 and textual notes
Huxley also drew attention to agreements in wording between versions. In evaluating testimony, that matters because several reports that share a source offer a different kind of evidence from several independent accounts. Variations alone do not establish what happened. They do give readers a reason to examine how accounts were composed and passed on before deciding which details are secure. In this instance, Huxley held that the evidence did not warrant the certainty Wace attached to the story. Huxley’s “Agnosticism: A Rejoinder”
The point applies beyond this passage. Someone can accept that a text preserves an important religious teaching while asking a separate historical question about an event it describes. Wace saw reasons to trust the testimony behind the teaching. Huxley asked how far that trust could carry a reader when comparing individual reports. Their exchange shows why stating the claim under discussion matters. Believing that a text has religious authority and judging how reliably a specific detail was transmitted involve different kinds of argument. Henry Wace’s reply in The Nineteenth Century Huxley’s “Agnosticism: A Rejoinder”
Conclusion
For Huxley, agnosticism was a discipline of matching what one claims to the grounds available for the claim. Wace’s reply made the role of revelation and testimony explicit. Reading the two writers alongside the Gospel accounts shows the difference between asking what a story teaches, what its versions agree on and how much confidence a reader can place in a detail. The debate gives concrete meaning to a term that often enters conversation as a general label for doubt. Thomas Henry Huxley’s “Agnosticism” Henry Wace’s reply in The Nineteenth Century Huxley’s “Agnosticism: A Rejoinder”
Published by Ralf. About our editorial process.




